ArcGIS Review: Is ArcMap the Best GIS Software?

ArcGIS Desktop

97
9.7

Cartography

9.8/10

Analysis

9.6/10

Editing

9.7/10

Data Management

9.8/10

Pros

  • Scalability for extra capability
  • Solid geoprocessing framework
  • Beautiful cartography options for print and web maps
  • Full set of editing and topology tools
  • ArcGIS Online for mobile apps and webmaps

Cons

  • High cost for usage and maintenance
  • License levels brings limited tools for basic
  • Interoperability underachieves in accepting non-common formats

ArcGIS Review: Is ArcMap the Best GIS Software?

In this ArcGIS review, we’re going to explore:

  • What are some of the pros and cons of ArcGIS?
  • How is ArcGIS different from other GIS software?
  • If you don’t use it already, should you consider using it?

Let’s get started below.

DISCLAIMER: We don’t work for or sell ArcGIS products on this page. This is an honest review from years of experience in the industry.

PROS

Scalability

ArcGIS is like a Swiss Army knife in GIS software. The best part? You can extend it to fit your organization’s needs. By using ArcGIS extensions and add-ons, it’s the complete package for all GIS uses.

Geoprocessing

The foundation for geoprocessing in ArcGIS is rock-solid. It’s quick with loads of documentation. Despite the occasional error, the extensive range of tools in ArcToolbox is a key highlight.

Cartography

You can build powerful maps in ArcGIS. Not only for print. But you can construct maps in 3D and online too. If you don’t have any cartographic skills, ArcGIS has an endless supply of symbology to pick from.

Data

Without data, you don’t have mapping. In ArcGIS, there’s no shortage of data. All you have to do is perform a quick search in ArcGIS Online. This massive data warehouse returns thousands of GIS data sets. In fact, it’s so good that we ranked it #1 in our list of free GIS data sets.

Editing

When you edit data, you can customize it and call it your own. Editing data is easy in ArcGIS. The editing toolbox doesn’t only provide tools to build data. But it also gives you tools for snapping and ensuring quality with topology.

CONS

Interoperability

Consuming specific data types can be difficult in ArcGIS. Over the years, interoperability has improved. But it still lacks capabilities in consuming all data types and GIS formats.

Licenses

ArcGIS has different license levels. Each license provides availability to certain tools. ArcInfo is the highest license available. But if you only have a basic license, you can’t use the entire suite of tools.

Cost

By adding extensions, you add extra capabilities to ArcGIS. But unfortunately, it all comes at a high cost. Despite getting an excellent suite of tools, it’s costly for some organizations.

Summary: ArcGIS Review

In this ArcGIS review, we reviewed why ArcGIS has become the industry standard in GIS.

But at the same time, ArcGIS is a big machine with a lot of moving parts.

Experience goes a long way. But since most colleges use it, students graduate with basic knowledge in it.

All things considered, ArcGIS is always well ahead of the curve. We highly recommend it as your GIS software of choice.

2 Comments

  1. I completely agree with Derek. The fact that ESRI has a near monopoly on commercial GIS software shows its signs in the steadily worsening product. If you try QGIS or any other open source software and compare the loading, drawing, and computing times against those of ArcGIS, you’ll be blown away at the difference. In fact, I use(d) arcGIS on corporate machines with immense computational power while on QGIS I’m performing identical operations on my tiny ultrabook in over a 10th of the time it takes on arcGIS. If that isn’t bizarre, I don’t know what is.

    Do yourself a favour, skip arcGIS until they decide to put in some effort into their software.

  2. I’ve been using Arcgis for years. It’s gone from BAD to WORSE. Probably the slowest, buggiest, most unreliable piece of software out there. What other software locks itself out of it’s own maps? Corrupts it’s own shapefiles? Takes 10’s of minutes to open a single tiny map? etc…

    Arcgis is like playing a bad round of golf everyday. Yeah there are a few moments that play out ok, but most of the time you’ll be cursing at the monitor and wondering how this company is still in business.

    Do yourself a favor and use Global Mapper. It does 99% of the same things and it works EVERY TIME.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*